Happy Trails Computer Club

home > computers > backup > programs  
Backup Programs
When deciding which backup method or program you're going to use, be sure to think about the steps it takes to restore files from your backups and how you would test the results.

Simple backup methods

It is simple to back up files using Windows Explorer. Just "select" the files, folder or folders you want to backup > right-click the group of files that you've selected > choose copy > then paste them in the folder where you want to put your backup. You can also use right-click and drag to copy files to their backup destination. (left-click and drag is likely to do something you don't intend). [Caution]

"Zip" programs (not to be confused with Zip drives) give you another simple backup method. A "zip/unzip" program offers file compression and can be more convenient than copy and paste. Windows XP creates Zip files directly (compressed folders). UltimateZip is an excellent free zip/unzip program. [freeware] WinZip is another powerful compression program that's easy to use, but it's not free. [shareware]

CD Burner software can be used to create backups of course. They even let you save the list of files and folders you want to backup as a project list. That seems great, but there's a limitation. Suppose some of the files have changed. Say that one has been modified, one deleted and one added. There's usually a way to verify that the contents of a project have not been moved, deleted, renamed, or modified since the last time.

But there's a problem. There's usually no way to automatically add any new files to the project list (list of files to burn). The new files will not be burned to the CD unless you add them manually. If you forget to do it or miss some of them they won't be on the CD. One solution is to create a project list from scratch each time. Another is to first create a backup set, say with a Zip program or backup program, and then burn the backup set.

FreeByte Backup

This is a simple backup program. The major advantage is that after you can get a backup list defined you can save it as a "profile" and then repeat the backup whenever you want. That way, you won't forget which files you need to back up. You add the directories that contain the files you want, and use a filter to limit the backup to just the files types you want to include.

I'd advise against using FreeByte Backup for incremental backups because it relies on the "archive" bit to determine if the file has changed since the last time. I've found that isn't always a reliable method, and you're liable to miss some files.

ZipBackup

I tried ZipBackup just to see if it was something to recommend. It seems just right to me for the average user. Not too complicated, good user interface, does just what it should and no more. Most importantly, it's not too confusing to restore files with. Use the option to append the date and time to the backup filename. $29.95

Backup4all

I now use Backup4all to do my day-to-day backup, and I recommend it for those who want a more automated solution. It uses its own file catalog to keep track of what's been backed up and when. That's the only completely reliable way to do it -- you can sometimes miss files with other methods.

Backup4all is easy to use, once you get the hang of it, but it takes a while to learn to use it. You'll want to experiment with some (small scale) experimental backups to find out just how it works though. Backup4all Pro puts its backups in Zip files. That lets you restore single files with just a Zip file program in a pinch (Windows XP can do this just fine by itself too). [see warning before using Backup4all]

Microsoft backup programs

Windows 98 comes with a program simply called "Backup". Go to Start > Programs > Accessories > System Tools > and click the Backup shortcut. This is a powerful backup program, but a little clunky to use. I've used it extensively in the past with good results. Backups made with Windows 98 "Backup" cannot be opened with any other program, including the backup program for Windows XP, so don't try to use it to transfer your files to a new computer.

Windows XP Pro comes with a backup program called Windows Backup (NTbackup). [Click Start > Programs > Accessories > System Tools > Backup] The user interface is a bit intimidating, but if you're willing to experiment (using some unimportant or dummy files) you can probably figure out how to use it. It's virtually the same as the Windows 98 version, but the backup archives (file sets) are not interchangeable.

NTbackup can be used on Windows XP Home too, but it's normally not installed. You need to install it separately. It should be on your Windows XP install CD If you don't have a real Windows CD, NTbackup may be on your restore CD.
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;Q302894
http://windows.about.com/library/weekly/aa020203a.htm

Don't confuse "Windows Backup" (NTbackup) with "System Restore" for XP. They aren't the same -- they compliment each other. Don't expect NTbackup to perform a complete restore of your C: drive. And don't expect System Restore to backup your data (documents, financial records, pictures, email, etc.).
http://www.informationweek.com/story/IWK20020711S0009
http://www.woodyswatch.com/winxp/archtemplate.asp?2-n05
http://www.woodyswatch.com/winxp/archtemplate.asp?2-n06

ZDNet reports on backup programs in a series of articles
http://www.zdnet.com/anchordesk/stories/story/0,10738,2865424,00.html
http://www.zdnet.com/anchordesk/stories/story/0,10738,2866116,00.html
http://www.zdnet.com/anchordesk/stories/story/0,10738,2866547,00.html

Backup using drive images

You cannot use ordinary backup programs to back up your "system". Your system consists of Windows, drivers, etc., plus some critical sectors on your hard drive. These sectors cannot be handled correctly as files, which is how ordinary backup programs work. The solution is full system backups, using a program designed for the purpose. They make an exact bit for bit image of the complete partition. I wouldn't be without a drive imaging program.

BACKUP MEDIA
Diskette (floppy) Pro: Cheap, universal (but being phased out).
Con: Unreliable, small capacity, slow, limited life.
1-3 yr life.
Tape Drive Pro: Large capacity.
Con: No random access, slow, limited life.
1-3 yr life
Zip Drive Pro: Fast, somewhat universal.
Con: Expensive media, can be prone to failure.
2-10 yr life
CD-R Pro: Cheap media, large capacity, long life.
Con: Slower than a hard disk or Zip drive.
Note: Life depends on the dye used.
CD-RWs are not as reliable as CD-Rs. CD-Rs are inexpensive enough to use exclusively, but don't buy cheap ones.
5-30 yr life
Hard Disk A second hard disk is very convenient storage for backups.
Pro: Fast with huge capacity.
Con: Not easy for the neophyte to install. Offsite storage is not very feasible.
2-10 yr life
External (USB) Hard Disk Another hard disk alternative. Read about my experiences before you rush out to buy one though.
Pro: Fairly fast with huge capacity and easy to install. Offsite storage is feasible. If you have one computer at Happy Trails and another at home, you can shuttle all your files between the two.
Con: The external case and power supply add about $120 to the basic hard disk cost.
2-20 yr life
"Don't put all your bits in one bucket." -- Curmudgeon
club stuff
help
search
site map
computer
local
online
topics
computers
files
backup
maintain
upgrade
help
software
hardware
internet
security